Leaked emails show MI5 ran a secret campaign to weaken or kill Britain's Hillsborough Law, a bill that would make it a crime for officials and spies to lie to or hide information from public inquiries. According to The Grayzone, MI5 chief Ken McCallum and former director Eliza Manningham-Buller lobbied ministers and peers for an MI5 exemption. McCallum privately admitted the bill was hard to oppose because opposing it "looks like one is against telling the truth." The agency fighting this law has already been caught lying to courts and inquiries.
Key points
- Leaked emails show MI5 lobbied to exempt itself from or kill the Hillsborough Law, which criminalises lying to inquiries.
- MI5 chief Ken McCallum admitted opposing the bill "looks like one is against telling the truth."
- Former MI5 chiefs in the House of Lords kept a list of "allies" to weaken the bill.
- MI5 has been found to have lied about the Manchester Arena bomber, Stakeknife and Agent X.
- The bill faces a Lords vote that could delay or amend it.
The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, known as the Hillsborough Law, would create a "duty of candour." Officials who lie to investigators could face 2 to 14 years in prison. It is named after the 1989 Hillsborough disaster, where 97 Liverpool fans died. Inquiries later found police falsified and suppressed evidence to blame the fans. The Commons passed the bill in July. It completed its Lords committee stage on October 21 and now faces a Lords vote. The Lords can delay it for a year or force amendments.
How the law came about
After 1989, the Hillsborough families called for a legal "duty of candour" so officials would have to tell the truth. Over the years they raised about £63 million in legal fees. Barrister Pete Weatherby KC, who represented the families, helped draft the bill. Andy Burnham first brought it to Parliament in 2017 as a private member's bill. It never reached a second reading, and the Conservative governments that followed did not take it up.
Other cover-ups kept the pressure on: the Post Office scandal, the Grenfell Tower fire that killed 72 people, the infected blood scandal and the nuclear test veterans. The Labour government introduced the bill in the Commons on 16 September 2025.

Illustration (AI-generated): a memorial for the 97 who died at Hillsborough.
According to the emails obtained by The Grayzone, McCallum used a private, pseudonymous email address to update Manningham-Buller. He wrote that he had tried to negotiate "a bearable version of the Hillsborough Law" with Andy Burnham's team before Burnham took office as Prime Minister. MI5's talking points said the bill risked "serious damage" to national security, would tie up officers in court and scare off foreign partners.
An MI5 official named David R. wrote that the agency was "in a good place with ministers on the need to carve us out of it." His plan was to publish an MI5 "code of ethics" to show the agency was already candid, so the duty would not need to apply. Victims' families later forced the government to include MI5 in the bill.

The Grayzone reports Manningham-Buller, who sits in the Lords, worked with fellow former MI5 chiefs Andrew Parker and Jonathan Evans to build a "list" of "allies" in the upper chamber. Names discussed included David Anderson, Alex Carlile, Peter Ricketts and Mark Sedwill. Manningham-Buller spoke privately with Lord Richard Keen and Lady Simone Finn. Keen told her they were "inclined to oppose the whole bill." An MI5 officer called Gareth M. said the agency was confident it could brief Finn and Keen.

Illustration (AI-generated): the House of Lords, where former MI5 chiefs sit.
MI5 knew its record was a problem. McCallum flagged the 2017 Manchester Arena bombing, where 22 people were killed. British intelligence had a covert relationship with bomber Salman Abedi and his family. An anonymous MI5 witness lied to the inquiry. The Operation Kenova report, published December 2025, criticised MI5 for hiding its relationship with "Stakeknife," an IRA informant described as a serial killer. In July, an Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office report found MI5 lied to multiple courts about "Agent X," a violent neo-Nazi informant it protected.
According to The Grayzone, references to MI5 in a Daily Telegraph article on Stakeknife and Agent X were removed on MI5's orders. In the Lords debate in May, Baroness Shami Chakrabarti warned that "a blanket exemption for the security agencies would be no kind of Hillsborough Law at all."
The fight over a spy exemption started in January
The leaked emails are not the first sign of MI5 pushing back. In January 2026 the government added an amendment that made cooperation by intelligence staff depend on approval from the head of their own service, with oversight by Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee. The committee did not support it. Labour MP Ian Byrne tabled an amendment to remove the exemption. BBC News reported at the time that McCallum spoke to some MPs to break the deadlock. The Grayzone's emails show what MI5 was saying in private.
Not the first leak
The Grayzone has published earlier stories from what it describes as leaked MI5 emails. In July 2026 it reported that McCallum and Manningham-Buller worked behind the scenes on the push to ban Iran's Revolutionary Guard as a terror group, and on the National Security Act, which created new offences for disclosing state information. In one email McCallum thanks Manningham-Buller for her "support [and stamina] in getting the NS Act over the line." In August it reported that MI5 tried to recruit a BBC leader while the broadcaster was investigating the agency.

Timeline. Sources: The Grayzone; Wikipedia; Press TV.
What happens next
The bill passed the Commons on 14 July 2026 and had its second reading in the Lords on 1 September 2026. The Lords can delay it by up to a year or send it back with amendments. The government wants the law in force by April 2027, in time for the anniversary of the disaster.
As of 17 November 2026 we found no mainstream British coverage of the leaked emails and no response from MI5.
Related on iToldu:
Please log in or sign up to comment.